When fulfilling tax obligations, taxpayers are undoubtedly the weaker party and have less freedom in shaping their procedures or fulfilling their statutory obligations – especially when the regulations themselves and their high level of complexity do not facilitate this.
However, the substantive regulations provide specific protective and preventive tools that, by definition, guarantee special protection for taxpayers. Such tools guaranteeing special protection for taxpayers include:
The general rule is that taxpayers benefit from special protection when using one of the above tools – i.e., compliance with them cannot harm the taxpayer. This also applies if the above protective measures are not taken into account in the resolution of a tax case. In addition to taxpayers, the institution of interpretations or clarifications also applies to payers and collectors.
It is also important that if an interpretation changes, is declared expired, or is not taken into account in the resolution of the case, additional special protection is provided by the fact that proceedings in cases of tax crimes or tax misdemeanors (referred to in the Fiscal Penal Code) are not initiated, and proceedings initiated in these cases are dismissed. Furthermore, default interest is not charged.
Special protective measures may also be applied by newly established entities – if they complied with an interpretation issued before the entity was established.
Generally, this occurs when a company complies with a tax ruling issued before the company’s formation – when the ruling was issued at the request of the persons planning to establish the company. Similarly, it occurs when a company complies with an individual ruling issued by a tax group or VAT group, issued before the establishment of the tax group or VAT group, if the ruling was issued at the request of the company planning to establish the tax group or VAT group.
The above principles will also apply to a family foundation (interpretation at the request of the founder), a branch of a company, or an inherited enterprise.
The protective provisions do not apply if the subject of the request for an individual ruling is an activity that is the subject of a decision regarding:
The above does not apply if the tax advantage resulting from the tax ruling arose in connection with the application of a general ruling, tax clarifications, or established interpretation practice. Obligation to Pay Tax
Compliance with an individual tax ruling after its delivery to the taxpayer protects the creation of a tax liability (of course, if the ruling is in the applicant’s favor), as does compliance with clarifications, general tax rulings, or established tax ruling practices.
However, if the tax liability results from an event occurring before the individual tax ruling is delivered or the general tax ruling is published, compliance with a protective measure does not exempt the taxpayer from the obligation to pay tax.0
Furthermore, the protective measures mentioned above are not the only means of protecting from tax authorities. Tax regulations include additional tools that effectively reduce tax liabilities, reduce the risk of sanctions and fines imposed by tax authorities, and allow for the application of mitigating circumstances for tax offenses.
More detailed information can be found in subsequent articles in the series “Taxpayer Protective Principles and Measures.”